| Platinum | Cheese Muenster |
| Gold | Two Fat Guys From Brooklyn |
| Silver | St Lucie Bakery |
| Bronze | Bella Roma Bakery & Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Bomboloni Bakery Café |
| Top Pick | Brooklyn Water Bagels |
| Top Pick | Jimmy John's |
| Top Pick | Miranda's Subs and Bakery |
| Top Pick | The Shrimp King |
| Top Pick | Which Wich |